When Your “What if” won’t let Go

Thoughtful biblical counseling for fear, intrusive thoughts, and the patterns that keep you stuck

IF this sounds like you


A woman with dark, shoulder-length hair sitting on a bench against a wooden slat wall, writing in a notebook. She is wearing a sleeveless beige top and brown pants. There is a framed abstract artwork beside her, and sunlight casts shadows on the white wall behind her.

“I have thoughts I never wanted but can’t stop thinking.”


Someone thinking about the wave of intrusive thoughts that come again and again.

“I live on alert waiting for the next wave.”


A woman with short blonde hair wearing an orange sleeveless that is thinking about how intrusive thoughts dominate her life.

“What if the doctors missed something or I get a disease?”


A woman in a black dress arranging flowers reflecting on harm OCD.

“What if I hurt someone even though I don’t want to?”

You have your own story, but you are not alone

Resource Hubs

  • Understanding What's Going On

    Make sense of what you have been living through

  • Stuck Thoughts

    Learn why some thoughts are hard to get rid of

  • Responding Differently

    Realize you don’t have to engage like you always do

  • Faith & Fear Tangled

    Learn about what is sometimes called moral scrupulosity

  • Getting Back To Life

    Get assistance in returning to daily tasks

  • Helping Loved Ones

    Learn how to encourage someone healthily

Articles and resources organized around the questions and thought patterns that surround fear, anxiety, OCD, and intrusive thoughts—and can leave you feeling stuck. Choose the area that sounds most familiar and begin there.

Close-up of the word 'event' in black text with small graphic elements around it.

THE REALITY

Things may go wrong.

Fear might still be there.

Life may not go as hoped.


THE RESPONSE

I don’t need to have certainty.

I won’t ever feel totally ready.

I can still move forward.


THE RESOLVE

I will trust through the dark.

Fears will shout.

What if → Even If.

“What if?” makes life smaller as you keep searching for one more answer, one more reassurance, one more reason to feel certain. Biblical counseling helps you step out of that cycle by learning to trust God in the uncertainty. Not because you can know the feared thing will never occur—but because fear does not get the final word. You can learn to say, “Even if.”

Comparison of two approaches to living: the old way involves a cycle of asking 'What if?', analyzing, reassuring, and temporary relief, which never ends. The new way involves noticing, accepting, and moving forward to live without waiting.

About

You know intimately what it’s like to believe that if you could just stop thinking about it, everything would be okay.

  • If the thoughts would just quiet down

  • If the fear would only leave

  • If the feeling of certainty would finally be there

Then maybe you could begin living again.

For a long time I believed that too.

What I eventually learned changed not only how I understood intrusive thoughts, anxiety and OCD–it changed how I understood peace itself.

It was found in learning a different response.

Today I help those who feel ensnared with intrusive thoughts, anxiety and relentless “what if” thinking learn how to move forward–not because every question has been answered, but because they no longer have to wait for certainty before living faithfully.


Cody Shores M.A.B.C, M.DIV

Master of Arts in Biblical Counseling & Master of Divinity

2013 Gained Certification - Association of Certified Biblical Counselors

20+ Years of Pastoral Ministry, Training & Teaching

Online & In-person Biblical Counseling Available Nationwide

Frequently Asked Questions

You don’t have to

STAY STUCK

You may not be able to choose every thought that enters your mind, but you can decide how to respond to it.